Insights, tools and research to advance journalism

Comments

Some news organizations are finding that comments can lead to increased revenue and reader loyalty, WAN-IFRA’s 2016 report on online commenting finds

Most of the news organizations surveyed in WAN-IFRA’s 2016 Global Report on Online Commenting said that comments are important (53%), but “closing the comment section is increasingly a strong consideration” because of the poor quality of comments. However, the report also found that some news organizations are finding success with comments. At The New York […]

Posting rules at the top of the comment section leads to more comments and more civil comments

According to a study of Reddit section r/science by CivilServant, posting the rules for the comment section can lead to more comments and prevent problematic comments. CivilServant’s research found that adding a sticky comment with the rules makes it 7.3 percentage points more likely that a newcomer’s comment will not have to be removed. And, […]

Can you moderate 5 NYT comments?

The New York Times is helping its readers get a taste of the work and thought process that goes into moderating comments with a comment moderation test. With some rules as background, readers are given five comments, which they can then approve or reject. Once the reader makes their choice, they’re then given an explanation […]

Journalists do read and respond to comments, new research from the Engaging News Project finds

New research from the Engaging News Project finds that journalists do actually read and respond to comments. Based on interviews with 34 journalists, all journalists interviewed said they read comments at least occasionally and two-thirds of those interviewed said they responded to commenters at least occasionally. And while some journalists were more enthusiastic about reading […]

Why more readers should frequent the comment section

While some are giving up on the comments section, Natalie Jomini Stroud says there’s still compelling evidence that the comment section can be good for both readers and news organizations. Comments provide an important way for journalists to interact with their readers. And with a focus on making the comment section a more civil place, […]

A new resolution in NYC would accept online comments as official feedback on proposed legislation

New York City council members James Vacca and Ben Kallos are proposing a new resolution that would make it easier for people to comment on proposed legislation: The resolution would require the city’s government to accept online comments as official feedback on legislation. Residents can currently only have their opinions officially recognized by showing up […]

Ideas from The Guardian’s comments hack day: A tool to let authors set the tone of the comments and a tool for curating comments

At The Guardian’s two-day hack event last week, developers presented ideas and tools for improving The Guardian’s comment section. Some of the ideas that surfaced: A tool called “Setting the Tone” allows post authors to post comments alongside the articles to set the tone of the discussion. An idea from Guardian readers suggested curating comments […]

Google says having a community and healthy comment section can help with search ranking

Though quite a few news organizations are cutting the comment section, Google’s Gary Illyes says that having a healthy comment section can actually help your search ranking. But this doesn’t mean that comments are the easy way to higher Google rankings: Illyes emphasizes that quality content and good links are ultimately more important to Google […]

Need to Know newsletter

The smart way to start your day

Each morning we scour the web for fresh useful insights in our Need to Know newsletter. Sign up below.

Featured topics

Go deeper on…

Dive deep on everything we produce about these key topics.

Strategy Studies

The best practices for innovation within news organizations

This Strategy Study presents examples and insights about journalism innovation, offering actionable advice and methods to move your journalism and business forward.